Analyzing the Hate for the 'Cars' Franchise

Analyzing the Hate for the 'Cars' Franchise

As a lifelong fan of animated movies, there's one franchise that has left me with mixed feelings: the "Cars" trilogy.

  • My journey with the "Cars" franchise began with the release of the first movie. I was excited to see Pixar's take on a world inhabited by anthropomorphic vehicles, and to some extent, it delivered. The quaint town of Radiator Springs, Lightning McQueen's character arc, and the nostalgic atmosphere drew me in. Yet, I couldn't help but feel that something was missing. While "Cars" had its moments, it didn't quite capture the magic of previous Pixar classics like "Toy Story" or "Finding Nemo."
  • When "Cars 2" arrived, I was puzzled by the shift in tone. Espionage, international intrigue, and Mater taking center stage left me scratching my head. It felt like a departure from what Pixar had excelled at emotionally resonant storytelling. The criticism directed toward the film's reliance on action over substance resonated with me. The cultural stereotypes portrayed in certain characters also left a bitter taste.

  • "Cars 3" attempted to course-correct by returning to a more character-driven narrative. Lightning McQueen's struggle to adapt to a changing racing landscape and his mentorship with Cruz Ramirez had potential. While the film was an improvement over its predecessor, it still fell short of the deep emotional impact that Pixar's best films had on me.

While these movies have their fan base and positive aspects, they also face some criticism and negative reception. Here are a few reasons why some people might express dislike or criticism towards these films:

  1. Target Audience: Many critics argue that the "Cars" franchise is more geared toward a younger audience, and the storytelling and humor may not resonate as strongly with older viewers compared to some other Pixar films that are known for their multi-layered narratives and emotional depth.

  2. Comparisons to Other Pixar Films: Pixar has a reputation for creating emotionally rich and innovative animated films that appeal to both children and adults. Some viewers might compare the "Cars" movies to other successful Pixar films like "Toy Story," "Finding Nemo," and "Up," and find them lacking in terms of storytelling complexity and thematic depth.

  3. Cultural Stereotypes: "Cars 2" in particular faced criticism for its portrayal of certain international characters and settings, which some viewers found to be based on cultural stereotypes. This portrayal was seen as insensitive and not in line with Pixar's typically inclusive and respectful approach.

  4. The shift in Tone: The first "Cars" film was relatively well-received, but the franchise took a different direction with "Cars 2" by focusing more on the action and espionage elements. This shift in tone and genre might not have resonated as well with fans of the original film or with audiences looking for a more traditional Pixar experience.

  5. Story Execution: Some critics argue that the plots of the "Cars" sequels are not as compelling or engaging as those of other Pixar films. The storytelling in "Cars 2" was seen as convoluted, and while "Cars 3" attempted to return to a more character-driven narrative, it still received mixed reviews.

  6. Merchandising Focus: The "Cars" franchise is known for its extensive merchandising, including toys, clothing, and other products. Some viewers feel that the franchise prioritizes merchandise sales over storytelling quality, leading to a perception that the films are more of a marketing strategy than genuine artistic endeavors.

  7. Comparison to Other Pixar Franchises: Pixar has created several successful franchises like "Toy Story," "Finding Nemo," and "The Incredibles." In comparison, the "Cars" franchise might not have reached the same level of critical acclaim or widespread popularity.

Reflecting on the criticism surrounding the "Cars" franchise, it's evident that the movies face an uphill battle. The franchise is often compared to the high standards set by other Pixar classics, which might be a bit unfair. Perhaps the original "Cars" was caught between its target audience: too simple for adults seeking depth and too mature for the younger crowd.

  1. $560 Million: "Cars 2," despite facing criticism, managed to gross over $560 million worldwide at the box office compared to $120m for Cars 1 and $383m for Cars 3. This demonstrates that while the film might not have been a critical favorite, it still found commercial success.

  2. 8-Year Gap: The time between the release of "Cars 2" in 2011 and "Cars 3" in 2017 was an 8-year gap—the longest period between sequels for any Pixar franchise. This extended period allowed for a recalibration of the franchise's direction.
  3. 39% Rotten Tomatoes Score: "Cars 2" holds a 39% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, making it one of the lowest-rated Pixar films on the platform. This highlights the divergence between critical consensus and audience enjoyment.

  4. 2 Academy Award Nominations: Despite the franchise's criticism, the original "Cars" film was nominated for two Academy Awards: Best Animated Feature and Best Original Song for "Our Town." This underscores the film's ability to resonate with certain aspects of the industry even while facing backlash from some quarters.

The franchise's emphasis on merchandising also fuels skepticism about its artistic intentions. It's easy to perceive the films as vehicles (pun intended) to drive toy sales rather than genuine storytelling endeavors.

Despite the criticism, I find a silver lining. The "Cars" movies have their charm and a dedicated fan base, especially among younger viewers. They offer a lighthearted, nostalgic escape into a world where cars have personalities. While the franchise might not hold the same emotional weight as Pixar's masterpieces, it still has its moments of joy and entertainment.

In the end, navigating the crossroads of "Cars" franchise criticism requires acknowledging its flaws while also appreciating its attempts to bring smiles to audiences' faces. It serves as a reminder that even beloved creators like Pixar can stumble, but their willingness to explore different directions is a testament to their commitment to innovation and creativity.

Discover how fast can a car truly sink in water. We delved into the intriguing science behind the factors that influence the speed of submersion, from car size to weight distribution, in a riveting exploration that might just change the way you think about cars and water. Prepare to be amazed by the unexpected as you click on the link to unveil the secrets of a car's aquatic descent in How Fast Does a Car Sink in Water? If not, don't miss out to witness the incredible process of How Does a Car Crusher Work?

Efforts have been made to get the information as accurate and updated as possible. If you found any incorrect information with credible source, please send it via the contact us form
Author: Sky Hoon
He loved the future of self driving car and cannot wait for one. In the meantime, he loved to read up all about car and components like a computer.
Read His Personal Blog
Back to blog